Land Dispute

Have you ever requested land papers from the National Archives? Although I have quite a few potential requests that I could make, I’ve only requested a couple of them. One request was for the papers associated with the claim of Hiram M. Curry in Peoria County, Illinois.

While Hiram M. Curry filed for and paid for 35.36 acres in the south west quarter of section five of township number 10 north of the base line in range number nine East of the 4th principal meridian, the claim was contested by Isaac Underhill.

While several of the affidavits claim bribery of witnesses by Isaac Underhill, Hiram Curry’s claim #8250 was eventually cancelled. These land entry papers are an interesting read and well worth whatever I spent to obtain the copy.

National Archives
Land Entry File

Curry, Hiram M.
Certificate #8250
Land Office: Quincy, Illinois

page 1

I do solemnly swear that I was in actual occupancy
of and raised a crop on the South west fractional
qr of Sec 5 town 10 North of Range 9 East of the
4th principal Meridian in the year 1833 and
that I was in actual possession and occupancy
of the same at the passage of the law on the 19th
of June 1834 and am still in possession and I
hereby apply to enter the same by preemption
agreeably to the Act of Congress n that care
made and provided
Hiram M Currey

Sworn to and subscribed before me n this
19th day of March 1836
Linus Scovill JP

We do solemnly swear that Hiram M Currey was
in actual occupancy of and raised a crop n the south
west fractional qr of Sec 5 in Town 10 North of Range
9 East of the 4th principal Meridian n the year
1833 and that he was in actual occupancy of the same
on the 19th of June 1834 and still is in possession
and that we are not interested or directly or indirectly
in his obtaining a preemption
Silas Allen
James Cannon
Harris (his mark) Whitaker

page 2
shall be entitled to receive a patent for the lot above described
Pre Act 1834
Saml Alexander Register

Charles [Ballance] of Peoria of lawful age agrees
and says in addition to his foregoing that he
has been acquainted with Hiram M Curry
since early in 1832 that in the latter part
said year this deponent and said Curry were
two of the commissioners appointed by the County
of Peoria to locate a road towards Knoxville to
pass on the North line of the above described
tract that his deponent was then in the house
of said Curry and has frequently been on
the premises same and states of his own knowl-
edge that said Curry has ever since resided on
said land with his family Neither has
he ever heard of his having had any other home
during said time nor has he heard of any
other person having a claim to said land
until the last week
C Ballance
Subscribed & Sworn to
before me on this 30th
day of May 1836
J. H. [Raentor] J. P.

page 3
Sworn to and subscribed before me on this 19th day
of March 1836
Linus Scovill JP

We do swear that the subscribing witnesses to the
within preemption proof are persons of
respectability and their oath entitled to credit
William Fletcher Thompson
Linus Scovill [Jun]
Sworn to and subscribed before me on this
26th day of March 1836
Linus Scoville J. P

I do hereby certify that the above named witnesses
are persons of respectability and their oath entitled
to credit
Linus Scovill JP

State of Illinois
Peoria County
To Wit – I William Mitchell clerk of the County
Commissioners Court for said County do certify that Linus
Scovill Esqr whose names appears to the foregoing certificates
was on the day of the date thereof an acting Justice of the Peace
in and for said County, duly commissioned and qualified
[seal] to [?] record in my office; and that as such
— [rest missing]

page 4
It is hereby certified, that in pursuance to law
Hiram M. Curry
of the County of Peoria and state of Illinois
on this day purchased of the Register of this Office, the lot or
South West fractional quarter
of section Five in Township No Ten North
of the base line Range nine West of the 4th principal meridian
containing 35 35/100
acres at the rate of one dollars and twenty five cents per acre amounting
to forty four dollars and
twenty cents for which the said
Hiram M Curry
has made payment in full as required by law,
No therefore e it known, that on presentation of this certificate the Commissioner of the
[?] [Hiram M Curry]
shall be entitled to receive a patent for the lot above described
Pre Act 1834
Saml Alexander Register
NOTE: CANCELLED written over top of document

Charles Ballance statement below above document

page 5 — same as page 4

page 6
State of Illinois
Peoria County
Clerks Office County Commission [?]
William Mitchell clerk of said court
do hereby certify that Linus Scovill Esqr whose
name appears to the within certificate was at
this time the same was made an acting Justice
of the Peace in and for said County duly
commissioned and qualified as appears of
record in my office and that as such full
faith and credit an act of right ought
to be given to be his official acts given
under my hand and seal
of said Court at Peoria this
25th day of May AD 1836
William Mitchell
Clk Co Comm PC

page 7
We James Cannon and Harris Wittaker
do solemnly swear that Hiram M Curry
is not entitled to a preemption to the South
west fractional qr of sec no 5 10N 9 East
for which he has our evidence to his
preemption papers bearing date 19th March
aD 1836 We were altogether unacquainted
with the boundarys of said fractional qr
until a recent survey of the same
and hereby swear that said Curry
never cultivated any part thereof to
our knowledge as set fort in said
preemption papers
James Cannon
Harris (his mark) Wittaker

Sworn to and subscribed before me
this 24th day of May 1836
Linus Scovill
Justice of the Peace

page 8
I William M C Bogardus hereby make
oath that Hiram M Curry is not entitled
to a preemption to the SW factional qr
of Sec No 5 10 North 9 East for which
he has my affidavit concerning I do
not want the Register to receive said
affidavit as there is a mistake in the
same and further that I swear
that the section lines do not
come within three or four rods of the
fence whee he states that he cultivated
the same, and further one of the witnesses
is Curry’s own son; and the other is
under age
W M C Bogardus

State of Illinois
Peoria County
I Lewis Bigelow, an acting
Justice of the peace within and for
the county of Peoria, hereby certify that on the 23 day
of May AD 1836 the above named William M C Bogar
dus personally appeared before me and made oath to
the truth of the foregoing affidavit by him sub
scribed
Lewis Bigelow, J. Peace

Page 9
State of Illinois
Peoria County
Clerks Office County Commissioners Court
William Mitchell clerk of said court
do hereby certify that Lewis Bigelow Esqr whose
name appears to the foregoing certificate was at
the time the same was made an acting Justice
of the Peace in and for said county regularly
commissioned and qualified as appears of
record in my office and as such [full]
[faith] and credit are and [of rights] ought to
be given to all his official acts In tes-
timony whereof I have hereunto
[subcribed] my hand and seal of said
Court at Peoria this twenty fifth
day of may AD 1836
William Mitchell
Clk

page 10
I Alexander Fo[r]sh being of lawful age and first duly
sworn testify that sometime in the summer of the
year 1836 in the town of Peoria I heard a conver-
sation between Isaac Underhill and another indi-
vidual respecting his [operations] at Rome on the
Illinois River in which said Underhill boasted of
having defeated the pre-emption of a settler in that
neighborhood by procuring his witnesses to swear that
their affidavits by which they established the pre-emp
tion were not true. In that part of the conversation
which was in my hearing he stated distinctly that he had
paid one of said witnesses to wit William M. C. Bogar-
dus the sum of two hundred dollars or four hundred
dollars (I am not certain which) to procure him to go
before a justice of the peace and recant upon oath
his former affidavit My impression is that he
did not give the name of the person whose pre-emp
tion he had endeavored to destroy but he described it
as being a fraction and otherwise so spoke of it as
to leave no doubt that it was the pre-emption of
Hiram M Curry to which he alluded and further this
affiant saith not
Alex H Fa[sh]
State of Illinois
Peoria County
I William Martin a justice of the peace
in and for said county do hereby certify that
on the ninth day of November AD 183[7] person
ally appeared before me Alexander H Fa[sh] and
was by me sworn to the truth of the foregoing
affidavit given under my hand the date
aforesaid
Wm Martin JP

State of Illinois
Peoria County
I, William Mitchell, Clerk of the County
Commissioners’ Court for said county, do hereby certify that William
Martin Esquire, whose name appears to the foregoing certificate, was on
the day of the date thereof, an acting Justice of the Peace, in and for the county
aforesaid, duly commissioned and qualified, as it appears to me of record in my
office; and that, as such, full faith and credit are due to all his official acts.
In Testimony Whereof, I have hereunto set my
hand, and affixed the seal of said court, at Peoria,
this Seventh day of December 1839
William Mitchell Clerk

page 11
I Charles Ballance do solemnly swear that shortly
after Isaac Underhill had filed the affidavits of
William M C Bogardus, and others in the land office
to defeat H. M. Curry’s right of pre-emption to a tract of
land adjoining Peoria in the county of Peoria Ill that
said Curry stated tome that said Bogardus had ackn
owledged to him that said Underhill had bulied him
for the sum of four hundred dollars to swear to an affi
davit contradicting his former affidavit which he
had made to establish said Curry’s pre-emption
that supposing if said statement was
true it was not [susceptible] of proof [Issued] to the
attention to it Until about two months ago said Curry in-
formed me he could prove said [?] by Alexander H
Fash [first] not having an opportunity to take his
affidavit then and his residence being several
miles from here I had not a convenient opportunity
to take it until November 9th last past and it was not
then forwarded to the general land office because I
wanted to procure further testimony especially
the testimony of Luther Sears who was an associate
of said Underhill and who I understood from Fash
knew all about it On this day I called on said Search who stated
that he heard said Bogardus and Underhill bargain
ing about said affidavit. Underhill offered a price
to Bogardus if he would upon oath recant his former affidavit
Bogardus refused to do it for the price offered but agreed
to do it for a large price After or [number] offers were
made and refused a sum was agreed upon and

page 12
the affidavit was made out and sworn to by said Bogardus,
and the price paid by said Underhill, as he understood from
them both, but what was the amount paid said Sears
could not recollect. After said matter was arranged said
Sears stated that said Underhill explained the transaction
to him and told him that it was Hiram M Curry’s pre-
emption claim near Rome that said affidavit was
taken to defeat. Said Underhill explained his having to give
so high a price for this affidavit to be that in addition
to the reluctance of the witness to contradict himself, he was
interested in Curry’s claim, and it was necessary to give
him more then his interest [amounted] to to get him
to swear against Curry Said Sears who seemed to know all about
the said transaction stated that he had “no doubt there was
perjury n the business.” I then asked him I he would
give and affidavit stating these fact, to which he answer
ed that being a friend of Mr. Underhills he would not
give any statement on oath as the subject unless required
in a court of justice and in this case he would swear
to the facts as detailed to me and related above and further this affi
ant saith not
Charles Ballance
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 7th day
of December AD 1839. In Testimony whereof
I have hereunto set my hand and
seal of the county Commissioners Court
of Peoria County, State of Illinois this
day last above said
William Mitchell Clk

page 13
State of Illinois
Peoria County
I Linus Scovill of lawful age being
fist duly sworn depose and say that I am the
Justice of the peace of said county before whom
the witness so were sworn who established Hiram
M. Curry’s right of Pre-emption to the South West
fractional quarter o Section No 5 in township
10 North of the base line and range No 9 East of the
4th principal meridian and when James Cannon and Har
ris Whitaker were afterwards bought before me by
Isaac Underhill to recant upon oath the statements
they had formerly made I at first refused to
swear them to said last mentioned affidavits on ac
count of its apparently involving them in perjury
and I enquired of them their motive for so great in
consistency. They informed me that Isaac Underhill
and Jefferson Taliaferro (who had floated on said
Curry’s claim) informed them that they (said Under-
hill & Taliaferro) had had said land surveyed and
had ascertained that no part of the field which said
Curry had cultivated in 1833 was on said tract
of land and therefore as said Curry had during said
year cultivated nowhere else they were quilty of perjury
in swearing he had cultivated a part of said
tract during said year and that said Underhill
and Taliaferro had threatened to present them for
perjury unless they would recant upon oath
the statements aforesaid respecting said Curry’s
pre-emption. I further state that I am well
acquainted with all the parties and the premises in
dispute that said Curry is a poor man who to
my certain knowledge has lived upon the land
in dispute ever since some time in the year
1832 until a few months past his family has

page 14
been absent (as is said) upon a visit to distant
relatives That I called to see said Curry some
time the fall of of 1833 and found him sowing
a crop of what and had at the time a crop of corn
and pumpkins grown The field he was cultivating
was always understood to be the fraction of section
5 township 10 north of range 9 east partly on the
NW qr and partly on the SW qr but having nev
er surveyed it have not say possibly where our east
& west line would run but have no doubt that
the house and part of the field are on the SW frac
tional quarter Said witnesses are very young
and could I presume be easily frightened or per
suaded to make such recantation without any criminal
intention I was at the time said Curry settled on
said land living said neighborhood and have
ever since lived there Given from under my
hand this 28th day of January 1837
Linus Scovill (seal)
State of Illinois
Peoria County
This day personally appeared
before me William Mitchell
a notary public of said county Linus Scovill
personally known to me to be the identical
person who subscribed and sworn to the foregoing
instrument of writing and deposed that the
statements therein made are just and true
according tot he best of his knowledge & beliefs
I also certify that the said Linus Scovill is
a man of integrity & credibility and that his
statements on oath may be relied on Given
under my hand and seal notarial
at Peoria this 28th January AD 1837
William Mitchell
Not Pub PC

page 15
State of Illinois
Peoria County
I William Mitchell Clerk of the County Commissioners
Court with & for said county do hereby certify that
Thomas Phillips Esqr is the County Surveyor within and for the county
of Peoria aforesaid (duly commissioned & qualified) that his commission
was dated on the 12th day of August A.D. 1835 and will expire in
August 1839 as it appears to me of record in my office and
that his signature to the foregoing certificate is genuine
In testimony whereof I have herein set
my hand and seal of said Court at
Peoria this 15 day of May AD 1838
William Mitchell Clerk

I Charles Ballance upon oath do state that the above certificate of
Thomas Phillips as signed by him in my presence
C Ballance
Subscribed & sworn to before me
this 15 day of May AD 1838
William Mitchell
Clk County Commissioners
Court Peoria County
Ill

page 16
Surveyor’s Office
Peoria County
State of Illinois
I Thomas Phillips sur-
veyor of said county do
hereby certify that I have
surveyed section No five in township ten
North of the base line and range nine East of the
fourth principal meridian according to
the original field notes or copy of which I
have procured from the surveyor General
office at St. Louis and find by accurate
measurement that the East and West line run
ning through the middle of said section
runs through the field said to have been
cultivated by Hiram M. Curry in the year
1833 dividing it in such a manner as to throw
a part of said cultivation on the South
West fractional quarter and the residue which
is much the larger portion on the North
West fraction quarter of said section Given
from under my hand at my office this 26
day of November 1836
Thomas Phillips [SC]

page 17
survey map

State of Illinois
Peoria County
I Thomas Phillips County Surveyor within & for the aforesaid county; do
hereby state on oath that I surveyed in the year 1837 fractional section
5 10 North, Range 9 East of the 4 principal meridian; and that no part of
the south west fractional quarter, of the fractional section aforesaid [bore no]
appearance of ever having been enclosed or cultivated. The cultivation by which
it appears Hiram M Curry proved a right of preemption to the said fractional
quarter was on the adjoining [contested] quarter. The nearest part of the said cultivation
doe not come within fourteen chains of the fractional quarter claimed by Curry..
Deponent further states that a certificate signed by himself and forwarded to the
Commissioners of the general land office, certifying that Curry’s improvements
were on said fraction aforesaid; was an [imposition] practised on said deponent
by one Charles Ballance of Peoria, Ills; and that said deponent signed the same
without fully understanding the contents of said certificate; said deponent
further states from the best of his knowledge & belief the above plat of said
fractional qr claimed by Curry is a correct one: Given under my
hand this twenty fourth day of May in the year

page 18
One Thousand Eight Hundred & thirty Eight
[SL} Phillips CJPC
Subscribed and sworn t before me William Mitchell
clerk of the county Commissioners Court within and
for the County of Peoria and State of Illinois this
26 day of May AD 1838 Given under my hand
and seal of said Court at Peoria
this 26th day of May AD 1838
William Mitchell
Clerk

Sideways text
Survey& affidavit of
Thos Phililps County Surveyor
Peoria Cy Ill relative to
SW qr 5 10th 9E

In relation to Hiram M
Curry’s Claim to Sd qr section
G.S.O.
Filed by King & Wilson 9th
June 1838
C.S. P.
recd 9 Jun 1838

page 19
State Bank of Illinois 4 [? 4,20]
Receiver’s Office, Quincy, Illinois
No. 8250
May 30, 1836
Received from Hiram M Curry
Peoria County, Illinois the sum of
Forty four
dollars and twenty cents, being in full payment for the
South wet fractional
quarter of section No. five
Township No. Ten north of the base line of Range NO. nine
East of the 4th principal meridian, containing thirty five
acres, and 36/100 of an acre, at the rate of one dollar and twenty-five cents per acre
$44.20
Thos Carlin Receiver
Pre act 1834
Con[flictng] with entry 7392

page 20
Canceled
Certificate
8250
and proof belonging thereto
Certificate Canceled
[Ss] letter to R&R 3d Oct
1838 also letter
from the Hon John T Stuart
dated 30 Dec 1839 X Comm &
reply of 2d Jany 1840 & letter
of same date to R & R

page 21
No. 8250
30 day of May 183[4]
I Hiram M Curry
of Peoria
County of Illinois do hereby apply for the purchase of the South
West fractional qr of section numbered five
in township numbered ten north of range numbered
nine east of the fourth principal meridian,
containing thirty five 36/100 acres,
according to the returns of the Surveyor General, for which I have agreed with the Register to
give at the rate of one dollar and twenty five cents per acre.

I, Samuel Alexander, Register of teh land Office at quincy, Illinois, do hereby
certify that the quarter section above descried contains 35 36
acres, as mentioned; and that the price agreed upon is $1 25 per acre
Pre Act 1834
Conflicting 7392
Saml Alexander Register